On this page
Spirit caramel (E150a) in whisky: colour and the law
What E150a plain caramel is, what the Scotch and EU whisky rules allow, why colour is a poor guide to age, and how to find whisky with no added colour.
Some whisky gets all its colour from the cask; some has its shade adjusted with plain caramel colouring, known as E150a. Both can legally be Scotch. If you prefer a bottle with no added colour, start with our natural-colour whisky collection.
What is E150a?
E150a, also called plain or spirit caramel, is a dark colouring made by heating carbohydrates. It is not the same thing as a sweet caramel flavouring. The food additive specifications in Regulation (EU) No 231/2012, retained in UK law, define plain caramel as made by the controlled heat treatment of carbohydrates; acids, alkalis and salts may be used, but not the ammonium or sulphite compounds used for the other caramel classes, E150b to E150d. The Scotch Whisky technical file says plain caramel is a colouring, not a flavouring or a sweetener.
What does the law allow?
The Scotch Whisky Regulations allow water and plain caramel colouring to be added to Scotch. The EU definition of whisky (Annex I, category 2) also says whisky must not be sweetened or flavoured, or contain any additive other than plain caramel (E150a) used to adjust the colour. These are category rules: do not assume every whisky-style drink or liqueur follows them.
American rules differ. For example, the US Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau explains that bourbon whisky cannot contain added colouring, flavouring or blending materials; a flavoured or wine-finished product may need a different designation.
Why add caramel?
Casks do not all produce the same colour. The official Scotch Whisky technical file says each cask of Scotch has a different colour, and a blender aiming to match previous batches of a brand may use very small quantities of plain caramel to adjust it, a practice it calls traditional since the 19th century. It says colour comes primarily from the cask and that any adjustment should not exceed the natural range maturation casks can give.
Colour is a poor shortcut for age or quality. Wood, previous cask contents, refill history and maturation all matter, and added colouring can make the visual comparison harder still. A pale whisky is not necessarily young or light in flavour; a dark one is not necessarily older.
How the cask sets the colour
Three cask factors do most of the work:
- Wood and previous contents. Ex-bourbon barrels of American white oak usually give lighter straw and honey tones; European oak casks seasoned with Oloroso or Pedro Ximénez sherry give deeper copper and mahogany shades; port pipes and red wine barriques can add ruby or bronze notes; and new charred oak colours spirit quickly, which is why a young bourbon can be deep amber.
- Fill number. A first-fill cask has the most colour and wood compounds left to give, so it colours spirit fast. Second, third and fourth fills give colour much more slowly: a 20-year-old malt from a well-used refill hogshead can still be pale gold, which is often deliberate, because refill casks let the distillery’s spirit character show without heavy wood.
- Cask size. A smaller cask has more wood surface per litre of spirit, so colour and oak build faster in a quarter cask of about 125 litres than in a 500-litre sherry butt. Our maturation guide covers cask sizes.
None of these is visible on the label unless the producer says so, and none of them proves anything if caramel was added.
Can you taste it?
Caramel colouring is added to adjust appearance, not to sweeten whisky. Whether it changes a finished whisky’s flavour at the concentration used is debated, and the result may depend on the whisky and amount. We have not found enough robust evidence to promise either that it is always detectable or that it can never affect flavour. A preference for natural colour can also be about transparency, regardless of taste.
How to identify a bottle without added colour
Look for a positive statement such as “natural colour” or “no added colour” on the specific bottle, or ask its producer. A producer-wide policy can help, but check that it covers the release and bottler in question; independent bottlings may follow different practices. Silence on a label or a retailer page is not, by itself, proof that nothing was added.
German labels and retailer listings are a useful extra clue. Section 5 of the German food-additives ordinance (LMZDV) requires the words “mit Farbstoff” (with colouring) where colouring is used; paragraph 5 applies this to prepacked drinks above 1.2% ABV, with an exemption where the label carries a full ingredient list. That rule covers bottles sold in Germany. It doesn’t prove what a UK bottling contains: strengths, editions and batches can differ between markets, so treat a German “mit Farbstoff” as evidence about the matching German release, and check contradictory producer or label evidence.
Browse natural-colour whisky
Our no-added-colour collection compares current UK retailer prices for bottles identified by our catalogue. Coverage is incomplete, and producer policies and releases can change. If an additive is important to your purchase, check the label or confirm with the retailer or producer before buying. You can also browse non-chill-filtered whisky: it is a separate process, so one claim does not automatically imply the other.
Sources and review
Questions
Is E150a allowed in Scotch whisky?
Does a darker whisky have to be older?
What colour is Scotch whisky?
How do I find whisky without added colour?
About the author
