On this page

GuideCocktails and mixing

Best peated whisky cocktails: recipes and bottle choices

How to make the Penicillin, Smoky Cokey, peated highball, Islay Old Fashioned and Blood and Sand with smoky Scotch, and which bottles to use.

Peated whisky works in cocktails in two ways: as a small measure that adds smoke to the aroma, or as the main spirit in a long drink. The Penicillin does the first, with 7.5 ml of peated Islay single malt floated on a lemon, honey and ginger sour. The Smoky Cokey and the peated highball do the second, with a peated malt lengthened with cola or soda water.

If you are new to mixing with peat, start with the Penicillin, or with a highball if you want something simpler. Each recipe below follows a published version, linked in the sources at the end.

Skip to the Penicillin recipe

Illustration of a Penicillin: a cloudy gold drink over one large ice cube in a rocks glass, with a thin darker float of peated whisky on top and candied ginger on a cocktail pick.
Cocktail recipe By Tom Gregan

Penicillin

Sam Ross's Penicillin: blended Scotch shaken with lemon juice and honey-ginger syrup, served over one large ice cube with a float of peated Islay single malt.

Prep time 5 minutes
Servings 1 serving
Glass Rocks glass
Ice One large ice cube
Alcohol About 2.7 UK units (with whiskies at 40% ABV)

Ingredients

  • 60 ml blended Scotch whisky
  • 22.5 ml fresh lemon juice
  • 22.5 ml honey-ginger syrup (made ahead, method below)
  • 7.5 ml peated Islay single malt whisky
  • Ice for shaking, plus one large ice cube to serve

Equipment

  • Cocktail shaker
  • Strainer
  • Jigger or measure

Method

  1. Add the blended Scotch, lemon juice and honey-ginger syrup to a cocktail shaker with ice.
  2. Shake until chilled.
  3. Strain into a rocks glass over one large ice cube.
  4. Pour the peated Islay whisky gently over the top so that it floats.
  5. Garnish with a piece of candied ginger on a cocktail stick.
Garnish: Candied ginger on a cocktail stick
Bartender note: In his account of the drink published by PUNCH, Sam Ross says he never served it with a straw, because he wanted the smoke from the float to reach the nose first.

Honey-ginger syrup

Make the syrup a day ahead. Peel and thinly slice 100 g of fresh root ginger and put it in a saucepan with 240 ml of honey and 240 ml of water. Bring it to the boil, then reduce the heat and simmer for 5 minutes. Leave it to cool, then cover it and keep it in the fridge for 12 hours. Strain it into a clean bottle, keep it in the fridge and use it within three days.

This is the method Difford’s Guide gives with Sam Ross’s original recipe, which measures the honey and water as a cup each (about 240 ml). The five-minute preparation time on the card assumes the syrup is ready.

1. The Penicillin

Bartender Sam Ross created the Penicillin at Milk & Honey in New York in 2005. Blended Scotch makes the base, lemon brings sourness, and the honey-ginger syrup brings sweetness and ginger spice. The peated whisky goes on last and floats on the surface, so you smell the smoke before you taste the drink underneath.

PUNCH’s version of the recipe suggests Famous Grouse for the blended Scotch and Laphroaig 10 Year Old for the float.

Johnnie Walker Red Label: £21.19 at Master of Malt. A blended Scotch bottled at 40% ABV, for the base.

Famous Grouse 1L: £25.50 at Master of Malt. The blended Scotch PUNCH’s recipe names, here in a 1 litre bottle at 40% ABV.

Laphroaig Select: £28.50 at Master of Malt. A no-age-statement Islay single malt at 40% ABV, the same strength as Laphroaig 10 Year Old in the UK. Laphroaig selected it from casks of four of its styles and finished it in new American oak.

2. The Smoky Cokey

Illustration of a Smoky Cokey: dark cola and peated whisky over cubed ice in a tall highball glass, with a lime wedge in the glass.

The Smoky Cokey is peated Islay whisky topped with cola. It is a simple way to try smoke in a longer drink: the cola brings sweetness, and a wedge of lime adds a little sharpness.

Fill a highball glass with ice and add 45 ml of Lagavulin. Top it up with chilled cola, stir gently and garnish with a lime wedge. Lagavulin’s own recipe leaves the amount of cola to you; Difford’s Guide uses 105 ml in a glass of up to 300 ml. With Lagavulin 8 Year Old it comes to about 2.2 UK units.

Lagavulin 8 Year Old: £55.02 at Master of Malt. The whisky in Lagavulin’s own Smoky Cokey recipe, bottled at 48% ABV.

Lagavulin 16 Year Old: £72.95 at Master of Malt. The distillery’s main bottling since 1988, at 43% ABV, and the whisky Difford’s Guide names in the drink’s history.

3. The Peated Highball

Illustration of a Peated Highball: pale straw whisky and soda over cubed ice in a tall highball glass, with a strip of grapefruit peel.

A highball is whisky lengthened with soda water and served over ice. With so few ingredients, the whisky decides the flavour, so a peated malt makes a smoky long drink.

Add 50 ml of whisky to a highball glass filled with ice, top it up with 150 ml of chilled soda water and stir. Garnish with a lemon wedge or wheel, as in the whisky highball on Diageo’s malts.com, or with a twist of grapefruit peel and a shiso leaf, as on the Scotch and Soda that Toby Cecchini serves at the Long Island Bar in Brooklyn. With Talisker 10 Year Old it comes to about 2.3 UK units.

Talisker 10 Year Old: £42.45 at Hard To Find Whisky. A Skye single malt aged for at least 10 years in American oak and bottled at 45.8% ABV. Undiscovered Scotland describes Talisker’s whisky as peppery and moderately peaty.

Caol Ila 12 Year Old: £49.95 at Hard To Find Whisky. An Islay single malt bottled at 43% ABV. Undiscovered Scotland describes Caol Ila’s whiskies as of medium peatiness by Islay standards, so it is a gentler option.

4. The Islay Old Fashioned

Illustration of an Islay Old Fashioned: deep amber whisky over one large ice cube in a rocks glass, with a strip of orange peel.

An Old Fashioned is whisky stirred with a little sugar and bitters. Make it with a peated Islay malt in place of bourbon or rye and the smoke becomes part of the drink.

This version follows Laphroaig’s Smoky Old Fashioned, published with the distillery’s credit by Food Network UK. Add 50 ml of peated Islay single malt, 5 ml of sugar syrup and 2 dashes of Angostura bitters to a mixing glass filled with ice. Stir for 40 seconds, then strain into a rocks glass over fresh ice and garnish with orange zest. Laphroaig’s recipe uses cubed ice in the glass. Lagavulin’s Old Fashioned uses a single large cube instead, because a larger piece of ice melts more slowly. At 40% ABV it comes to about 2 UK units.

Difford’s Guide’s Islay Old Fashioned takes a different route, with rich demerara syrup (two parts sugar to one part water), Peychaud’s bitters and a lemon twist.

Laphroaig Select: £28.50 at Master of Malt. Laphroaig’s recipe calls for its 10 Year Old; Select is the distillery’s no-age-statement bottling at the same 40% ABV.

Ardbeg 10 Year Old: £39.95 at Hard To Find Whisky. An Islay single malt from ex-bourbon casks, bottled at 46% ABV without chill filtration. Ardbeg’s malt is peated to around 55 ppm.

5. The Blood and Sand

Illustration of a Blood and Sand: a red-orange drink served up in a coupe, with a cherry in the base.

The Blood and Sand is blended Scotch shaken with cherry liqueur, sweet vermouth and orange juice. Difford’s Guide notes that it first appears in Harry Craddock’s 1930 The Savoy Cocktail Book and is named after Rudolph Valentino’s 1922 film Blood and Sand.

The classic version uses equal parts: 22.5 ml each of blended Scotch, cherry liqueur, sweet vermouth and fresh orange juice. Shake with ice and fine-strain into a chilled coupe, then express a twist of orange zest over the drink.

For a smoky version, Difford’s Guide’s own recipe adds 5 ml of peated single malt to 22.5 ml of blended Scotch, keeps 22.5 ml each of cherry liqueur and sweet vermouth, and increases the orange juice to 30 ml. It is garnished with an orange zest twist and a cherry. Difford’s Guide puts the classic at about 1.8 UK units and its smoky version at about 2.

The blended Scotch and Laphroaig Select picks in the Penicillin section work for both parts.

Two more Scotch classics

The recipes cited for these two call for Scotch or blended Scotch, with no peated malt, so the base bottles from the Penicillin section suit them.

Bobby Burns

Illustration of a Bobby Burns: a deep red-amber drink served up in a coupe, with a lemon twist.

The Bobby Burns is Scotch and sweet vermouth with a little Bénédictine, a French herbal liqueur. Harry Craddock’s 1930 recipe gives equal parts Scotch and Italian vermouth with three dashes of Bénédictine. Difford’s Guide’s version of it uses 45 ml of blended Scotch, 45 ml of sweet vermouth and 7.5 ml of Bénédictine.

Stir them with ice, fine-strain into a chilled coupe and squeeze a strip of lemon peel over the top. Difford’s Guide puts it at about 2.8 UK units.

Rusty Nail

Illustration of a Rusty Nail: golden Scotch and Drambuie over ice cubes in a rocks glass, with a lemon twist.

The Rusty Nail is Scotch whisky with Drambuie, a liqueur made from Scotch whisky, honey and herbs. The International Bartenders Association’s recipe uses 45 ml of Scotch and 25 ml of Drambuie, poured into an old fashioned glass filled with ice, stirred gently and garnished with lemon zest. With Scotch and Drambuie both at 40% ABV, it comes to about 2.8 UK units.

Difford’s Guide notes that the ratio of Scotch to Drambuie varies widely, with about three parts Scotch to one of Drambuie the most common preference. Its own recipe uses 60 ml of blended Scotch, 20 ml of Drambuie and two dashes of Angostura bitters, stirred with ice and strained over fresh ice.

Sources and review

Where to go next

Questions

Can you use peated whisky in a cocktail?

Yes. Some well-known recipes are built around it. The Penicillin uses 7.5 ml of peated Islay single malt as a float on top of a blended Scotch sour, so the smoke sits on the surface. The Smoky Cokey uses 45 ml of Lagavulin topped with cola, and Lagavulin’s own recipe uses its 8 Year Old. A highball needs only whisky, soda and ice, so a peated malt changes its character directly. Laphroaig publishes a Smoky Old Fashioned made with 50 ml of its 10 Year Old, and Difford’s Guide adds 5 ml of peated malt to its Blood and Sand.

Who created the Penicillin cocktail?

Sam Ross, an Australian bartender, created the Penicillin in 2005 at Milk & Honey in New York. In his account published by PUNCH, it began as a riff on the Gold Rush, one of the bar’s best-selling drinks, made with Compass Box’s Asyla and with the sweetening split between honey and sweetened ginger juice. He then poured a float of Compass Box’s smoky The Peat Monster on top. The original specification, as Difford’s Guide gives it, is 60 ml blended Scotch, 22.5 ml lemon juice, 22.5 ml honey-ginger syrup and 7.5 ml peated Islay single malt.

Where does the Smoky Cokey come from?

Difford’s Guide traces it to Dave Broom, who tried Scotch whiskies with a range of mixers for his 2014 book Whisky: The Manual and found that Lagavulin works with cola. Colin Dunn, a whisky ambassador for Diageo, which owns Lagavulin, gave it the name Smoky Cokey and made it widely known. Lagavulin’s own recipe uses 45 ml of Lagavulin 8 Year Old in an ice-filled highball glass, topped with cola and garnished with a lime wedge.

About the author

Tom Gregan

· Writer

Tom came to whisky by way of cocktails and rum. As the mind behind CocktailDB.com he spent years on citrus balance, bitters and modifiers before John dragged him over to neat spirits.