On this page

Guide

Distillery pagoda roofs: Charles Doig and his ventilator

Why Scotch distilleries have pagoda roofs, how the Doig ventilator drew smoke evenly through a malt kiln, who Charles Doig was and where his roofs survive.

The pagoda on a Scotch distillery roof is a kiln ventilator. Charles Chree Doig, an architect in Elgin, designed it in 1889 for the malt kilns at Dailuaine distillery on Speyside, to give the fire beneath a steady draw of air whatever the wind was doing (Historic Environment Scotland). It was copied across Scotland and then outlived its job: few distilleries still dry their own malt, so most pagodas are now kept for how they look.

What a malt kiln needs from its roof

Malting ends in the kiln. Germinated barley, called green malt, lies on a perforated floor above the heat, and warm air rising through the bed stops the grain growing and dries it to around 5% moisture. Our production course covers the steps in kilning. Where the fuel is peat, the same rising air carries the smoke into the damp husks, which is how peated malt gets its phenols.

Peat smoke drying barley in a kilnPeat smoke drying barley in a kiln. Cupola vents the; smoke and steam; Damp green malt; takes on the smoke; Perforated kiln floor; Smoke rises through; the grain bed; Peat smoulders:; smoke, not flame; Phenols in the smoke, such as guaiacol and; cresol, cling to the damp husks.UNDERSTANDING WHISKY PRODUCTIONPeat smoke drying barley in a kilnCupola vents thesmoke and steamDamp green malttakes on the smokePerforated kiln floorSmoke rises throughthe grain bedPeat smoulders:smoke, not flamePhenols in the smoke, such as guaiacol andcresol, cling to the damp husks.The kiln then dries the malt to around 5% moisture.Uisge Beatha
Peat smoke rises through the perforated floor and into the damp green malt.

Before electric fans, nothing moved that air but the fire’s own updraft, which left through vents in the roof (kilning technology). The draught needed to pass through the whole bed evenly, so that every grain stopped growing at the same point. An uneven draught left some grain growing past its best and made poorer malt (Whiskipedia).

Before Doig: hoods and cowls

The first covers over a kiln’s ridge opening were small pitched hoods, a little roof over the hole to keep out rain and birds. A capped vent that lets smoke out only at its sides draws slowly, so the hood kept the kiln dry at the cost of its updraft (Whiskipedia).

Distillers then fitted revolving, conical cowls (Gavin D Smith, scotchwhisky.com). A cowl turned with the wind and used it to pull the smoke out, which helped, but the pull rose and fell with the wind’s strength. The kiln’s draught followed the weather, and the only way to correct it was to change the fire, which a large kiln answers slowly (Whiskipedia).

The Doig ventilator

Doig’s design came out of a site meeting at Dailuaine on 3 May 1889, as a replacement for the kiln’s revolving cowls. It was a kiln chimney that drew air from all directions to give the fire beneath a better draw (Smith).

How a Doig ventilator steadies the draughtHow a Doig ventilator steadies the draught. 1 Pitched hood; Kept the rain out but; slowed the updraft; 2 Rotating cowl; The draught rose and; fell with the wind; 3 Doig ventilator; Upturned eaves gave; an even draughtUNDERSTANDING WHISKY PRODUCTIONHow a Doig ventilator steadies the draught1 Pitched hoodKept the rain out butslowed the updraft2 Rotating cowlThe draught rose andfell with the wind3 Doig ventilatorUpturned eaves gavean even draughtCharles Doig first fitted it at Dailuaine distillery in 1889.Uisge Beatha
The pitched hood, the rotating cowl and the Doig ventilator

Three changes did the work. The cover curves outwards and then upwards at the eaves, the hood sits higher above the vent, and there are fewer horizontal louvres at its base, which together cut the resistance to the rising air (Whiskipedia). Historic Environment Scotland’s listing text adds that the ventilators were designed for practical use but also follow the Golden Ratio (LB46333).

The shape is why everyone calls it a pagoda, though it is properly known as the Doig Ventilator, and in building terms it is a cupola, a small structure crowning a roof. Distillery owners of the 1890s wanted one for its draw, for its looks and, in some cases, because their friends and rivals had installed one (Smith).

Charles Chree Doig

Doig was born on a farm in Angus in 1855, the son of an agricultural labourer. He worked for John Carver, an architect in Meigle, and in 1882 his family moved to Elgin, where he joined the land surveyor Harbourne Marius Strachan Mackay. He became a partner and was running his own practice by 1890 (Smith). Historic Environment Scotland describes him as a civil engineer and architect who designed a wide variety of buildings, with distilleries as his speciality (LB46333).

Smith credits him with professional involvement in no fewer than 56 distilleries. The work reached well beyond Speyside, to Highland Park on Orkney, Talisker on Skye, and Ardbeg, Caol Ila and Laphroaig on Islay. His sons Charles junior and Willie also became architects.

Fire destroyed the original pagoda head at Dailuaine in 1917. Doig died the following year, aged 63, after falling ill while shooting on moorland near Forres (Smith). His plans are held by the Moray Council Local Heritage Centre (The National Archives).

Where Doig’s roofs survive

Fire and modernisation took many of the originals (Whiskipedia), starting with Doig’s first at Dailuaine. Two survivors at distilleries are confirmed by their owner or their building listing, and a third, outside the industry, is very likely his.

At Annandale, near Annan in Dumfriesshire, Johnnie Walker & Sons bought the distillery in 1893 and added a Charles Doig pagoda kiln (Annandale). Its listing records the pagoda as added in the late 19th century (LB3507). The distillery was restored after 2007, made spirit again from 9 November 2014, and describes its roof as one of only five original Doig pagodas left, without naming the others.

At Ardmore, near Kennethmont in Aberdeenshire, the listing describes a distillery designed by Charles C Doig and established in 1898 for William Teacher & Sons, with a kiln house whose pyramidal roof carries a louvred pagoda cupola (LB49668).

The likely third is not a distillery. The former City Corn Mills on Wards Road in Elgin have a malting kiln that is probably Doig’s work of 1912, and the listing calls its ventilator “very likely” a Doig ventilator and an important survival (LB46333).

Pagodas today

Only a handful of Scottish distilleries still malt their own barley, so most pagodas are now purely ornamental (Smith). Springbank, Bowmore, Laphroaig, Highland Park, Balvenie, Kilchoman and Benriach malt some or all of their barley on their own floors (floor maltings). Most other distilleries buy malt from commercial maltsters, whose kilns use high-volume fans and indirect heat in place of a fire’s natural draught.

The roof stayed as a symbol. When Auchroisk was built near Keith in the early 1970s, and the Isle of Arran distillery two decades later, both were given pagodas for tradition’s sake with no kiln to vent (Smith).

Sources and review

Questions

Why do Scotch distilleries have pagoda roofs?

The pagoda is a ventilator on top of a malt kiln, where germinated barley was dried over a fire. Charles Chree Doig of Elgin designed it in 1889 for the kilns at Dailuaine distillery on Speyside, to replace revolving cowls whose pull changed with the wind. His design drew air in from all directions and gave the fire a steadier draw, and it was copied at distilleries across Scotland.

Who was Charles Doig?

Charles Chree Doig (1855 to 1918) was an architect and civil engineer in Elgin whose speciality was distilleries. Born on an Angus farm, he joined an Elgin land surveyor in 1882 and ran his own practice by 1890. Gavin D Smith credits him with professional involvement in no fewer than 56 distilleries, from Speyside to Orkney, Skye and Islay. His plans are held by the Moray Council Local Heritage Centre.

What is a Doig ventilator?

It is Doig’s name for the pagoda-shaped cover over a kiln’s roof vent. The cover curves outwards and then upwards at the eaves, sits higher above the vent than earlier hoods and has fewer louvres at its base, so hot air and peat smoke leave the kiln evenly in most weather. Historic Environment Scotland notes that its proportions follow the Golden Ratio.

Do distillery pagodas still work?

Only where a distillery still dries its own malt. Springbank, Bowmore, Laphroaig, Highland Park, Balvenie, Kilchoman and Benriach malt some or all of their barley on site; most other distilleries buy malt from commercial maltsters whose kilns use fans. When Auchroisk was built in the early 1970s and Arran two decades later, both were given pagodas purely for tradition.

About the author

John Fegan

· Editor

Hailing from the land of haggis and deep-fried Mars bars, John was always going to find his way to whisky. He has run Uisge Beatha since 2015 and Whiskipedia.com since 2020.