On this page

GuideIf you like X

Best whisky for rum lovers

Whiskies for rum drinkers: rum-cask finishes, bourbon's vanilla and toffee, and sherry-cask malts for fans of aged dark rum, with live UK prices for each.

If you drink rum, start with a whisky finished in rum casks, such as Balvenie 14 Year Old Caribbean Cask, or with bourbon, whose new charred oak gives vanilla, toffee and brown sugar. Drinkers of aged dark rum often like sherry-cask malts too. A rum-cask finish is one stage of the whisky’s maturation, so it adds a note of rum rather than making the whisky taste like rum.

How a rum drinker ended up here

I was a rum person long before I was a whisky person. For years my shelf was aged rums for sipping and a couple of workhorse bottles for the shaker, and whisky was the thing John poured when he wanted to start an argument. Most of what I knew about spirits I learned behind a home bar, balancing citrus and sugar and working out why one rum made a Daiquiri sing and another just made it sweet.

What finally got me across was the barrel. Plenty of the rums I loved had spent their lives in old bourbon barrels, so the first time I tasted a decent bourbon neat it was like meeting the previous tenant of a flat I’d been living in for years. Same vanilla on the walls. Same toffee in the cupboards. From there it was a short walk to Scotch, and John has been insufferable about it ever since.

So this guide is the route I’d give a friend who drinks rum: start with the whiskies that share a barrel with rum, then the ones that share its sweetness, then the ones that share the dried fruit of a properly old dark rum.

Guide

From the rum you like to the whisky to try

The shared flavours mostly come from the oak

  1. If you like

    The rum itself

    What they share

    A rum-cask finish adds a sweeter, fruitier note

  2. If you like

    Golden and dark rum

    What they share

    Vanilla and toffee from new charred oak

  3. If you like

    Aged dark rum

    What they share

    Dried fruit, raisin and spice from sherry casks

  4. If you like

    Jamaican rum

    What they share

    A strong, fruity style suits a full-flavoured peated malt

Prices are the cheapest current price we found and link to the bottle page. Infographic: Uisge Beatha, CC BY 4.0. Reuse it with credit.

Why rum and whisky overlap

Rum is distilled from sugar cane, usually molasses, and much of it is aged in ex-bourbon barrels. Whisky is distilled from grain. The flavours they share mostly come from the oak: vanilla, caramel and spice from charred American oak, and dried fruit from European oak. A rum cask adds something of the rum itself, usually a sweeter, fruitier note.

Whisky finished in rum casks

This is the obvious first step, and it’s where I started. These whiskies have spent their last stretch in a cask that used to hold rum, so there is something familiar on the nose before you’ve even decided whether you like it.

Balvenie 14 Year Old Caribbean Cask: £54.95 at Master of Malt. A Speyside single malt at 43% ABV, aged in traditional oak casks and finished in casks seasoned with Caribbean rum. If I could only hand a rum drinker one bottle on this page, it would be this one.

Glen Scotia Double Cask Rum Cask Finish: £39.00 at Master of Malt. A Campbeltown single malt at 46% ABV, finished in rum casks. A little more weight than the Balvenie, and a good one to try after it.

Teeling Small Batch Rum Cask Finish: £34.90 at Master of Malt. A blend of Irish malt and grain whiskey at 46% ABV, finished in ex-rum casks. This is the one I reach for when I want to swap rum out of a highball and see what happens.

Mossburn 12 Year Old Foursquare Finish: £59.73 at Master of Malt. A Speyside blended malt finished in casks from Foursquare, a rum distillery in Barbados. It is bottled at 57.7% ABV, so add water a few drops at a time until it opens up.

Bourbon for golden and dark rum drinkers

Bourbon must be made from at least 51% corn and aged in new charred oak containers, and it may not contain added colouring or flavouring. The fresh char is where its vanilla and toffee come from. Whiskipedia’s guide to bourbon casks explains why those barrels are then reused for Scotch and rum.

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked: £49.00 at The Whisky Shop. A Kentucky bourbon at 43.2% ABV, finished in a second new barrel that is heavily toasted and lightly charred. The one for dark rum drinkers: all that extra toasting pushes it towards caramel and brown sugar.

Maker’s Mark: £35.00 at The Whisky Shop. A Kentucky bourbon that uses red winter wheat instead of rye in its mash, which keeps the spice lower. My pick for anyone who likes their rum soft and round.

Four Roses Bourbon: £23.95 at Master of Malt. A Kentucky bourbon at 40% ABV. A lighter, easy-going bottle and a sensible one to keep for mixing.

Sherry-cask malts for aged rum drinkers

Sherry casks give dried fruit, raisin and spice, which drinkers of older dark rums often like. This is the section for the person who sips their rum neat from a small glass and gets slightly defensive when someone reaches for the cola. See the sherry-cask guide for more.

Aberlour 12 Year Old: £43.00 at The Whisky Shop. A Speyside single malt at 40% ABV from traditional oak and sherry casks.

Balvenie 12 Year Old DoubleWood: £50.28 at Master of Malt. A Speyside single malt at 40% ABV, finished in oloroso sherry casks. If you liked the Caribbean Cask, this is its older sibling’s way of doing things, with sherry where the rum was.

Reading a rum-cask label

Rum-cask whiskies are mostly finishes, and many are limited releases. The label may name the rum’s origin (Caribbean, Jamaican, a named distillery) but rarely says how long the finish lasted. “Rum cask” tells you what the cask held, not how much it changed the whisky. A named rum distillery tells you where the cask came from, which is worth knowing, but it still says nothing about how long the finish lasted. Every rum-cask whisky on the site is listed together.

Sources and review

Questions

What whisky tastes most like rum?

No whisky tastes like rum, but rum-cask finishes and bourbon come closest. Balvenie 14 Year Old Caribbean Cask is finished in casks that held Caribbean rum, and bourbon’s new charred oak gives the vanilla, toffee and brown sugar notes many aged rums share.

What is a rum-cask finish?

The whisky spends its final months in a cask that previously held rum, after ageing in other casks. Balvenie 14 Year Old Caribbean Cask (43% ABV) and Glenfiddich 21 Year Old, finished in Caribbean rum casks, are two long-running Speyside examples.

Can rum drinkers enjoy Scotch?

Yes. Fans of aged dark rum often like sherry-cask malts such as Aberlour 12 Year Old or Balvenie 12 Year Old DoubleWood for their dried fruit and spice. Drinkers who like the strong, fruity style of Jamaican rum may prefer a full-flavoured peated malt such as Talisker 10 Year Old.

Is spiced rum similar to bourbon?

They share vanilla and spice flavours, but for different reasons. Spiced rum has spices and often sugar added after distilling. Bourbon may not contain added flavouring or colouring, so its vanilla and spice come from the grain, mostly corn, and the new charred oak barrels it must be aged in.

About the author

Tom Gregan

· Writer

Tom came to whisky by way of cocktails and rum. As the mind behind CocktailDB.com he spent years on citrus balance, bitters and modifiers before John dragged him over to neat spirits.